Health coach and comedian, JP Sears, discusses how comedy can deliver different perspectives and help us get in touch with our emotions by teaching us to not be so rigid and attached to our own beliefs to the point that we can negatively impact our health and well being. JP also shares 3 affirmations that he lives by, plus his daily self-care rituals to center the mind, wake up the body, connect mind with body, and connect to feelings.
Episode Summary
On a recent Head First episode I talked with a health coach and satirist who built a following by poking fun at the wellness world: the gluten-free fads, the paleo dogma, the Instagram savasana shots. What pulled me in was that the joke runs on a real idea. You can take a health practice so seriously that the practice itself starts to hurt you. The punchline points at something measurable in the brain.
When does a healthy habit become an unhealthy one?
You can eat clean, exercise, meditate, and still end up worse off. My guest spent at least ten years, by his own account, locked into obsessive-compulsive health behavior. Spiritual practices, eating rules, exercise routines, all of it rigid. He coined a personal warning for it: the path you take to find yourself eventually becomes the path you lose yourself on. What works for a while works against you once you grip it too hard.
There is a name for the food version of this. Orthorexia describes an obsessive fixation on "correct" eating that crowds out flexibility, social connection, and quality of life (Bratman & Knight, 2000). The catch he named is sharp: when you are inside it, you cannot see it. He used to lecture audiences that orthorexia was a made-up shaming term, while he was living squarely in it.
The math he uses tracks with how I think about stress physiology. A clean food might raise your vitality by five units. The chronic psychological stress of policing every bite, scanning labels, and catastrophizing about a contaminated meal can cost you eleven. You net out negative. The food was fine. The relationship to the food was the problem.
What does rigid, dogmatic thinking do to the brain?
Cognitive rigidity runs on a recognizable pattern of circuit activity, and you can see correlates of it on a brain map.
Dogma narrows attention. When you hold a belief as certain, the brain stops sampling for disconfirming evidence. My guest described this directly: he could not tell whether his practices were working, because his dogma had already decided they worked, so he stopped checking. That is the threat-and-control mode of the nervous system doing its job. A rigid, controlling stance runs heavier on right-frontal threat-scanning circuitry and on the cortico-striatal loops that drive repetitive, rule-bound behavior. The same circuit involved in obsessive-compulsive patterns, the loop running through the orbitofrontal cortex, anterior cingulate, and striatum, biases the brain toward "I must follow the rule" over "let me see what the data show" (Menzies et al., 2008).
Certainty feels safe because it lowers the cost of monitoring. The price is that learning stalls. Flexibility depends on the prefrontal cortex staying online enough to update a prior when the evidence changes. This is well-established cognitive neuroscience: prefrontal regulation lets the brain hold a belief loosely and revise it (Miller & Cohen, 2001). When threat circuitry dominates, that updating slows down.
Why is curiosity better than judgment for your nervous system?
My guest framed his first mantra as "nothing is as it seems," which keeps him in a curious mind rather than a certain one. Curiosity orients toward growth. Certainty orients toward constriction and control. That maps cleanly onto what I teach in meditation.
When people start a mindfulness practice, they hit a wall of self-evaluation. I can't do this. My back hurts. My mind won't stop. That judgment is the threat-and-control system narrating the experience. The instruction I give is to replace the judgment with curiosity about the experience. Notice the pain. Notice the restlessness. Get interested in it instead of grading yourself. Curiosity recruits exploratory, approach-oriented processing instead of the defensive crouch. It is a lever you can pull in real time, and over weeks of practice the baseline can shift. The deeper mechanism is in the neuroscience of mindfulness training and in Mindfulness: Don't Just Do Something, Sit There.
The meditation teacher Shinzen Young puts it bluntly: your mind has led you astray whenever you reach a conclusion. The conclusion is the moment you stopped sampling. Curiosity keeps the sampling running.
Can disconnection hide inside a health obsession?
This is observation, not a controlled trial, so hold it as a hypothesis. My guest raised the possibility that an obsessive health regimen can function as a way to stay disconnected from people. If the rules are strict enough, you never have to share a meal, never have to compromise, never have to risk the vulnerability of connection. The avoidance gets dressed up as discipline.
I see versions of this in the brain maps and in what people describe. Rigid control is often a strategy the nervous system adopted to manage the threat of being hurt or rejected. The behavior looks like health. The function is protection. The system over-allocated toward control because, at some point, control kept it safe. The move is to give that system new data: small, tolerated doses of flexibility and connection that show the threat prediction was wrong. For more on how the brain runs threat prediction and how to train it down, see Biohacking Fight or Flight and Biohacking Anxiety.
What is a sane daily routine for the brain?
When I asked what actually keeps him regulated, the answer was a stack of practices that line up well with the circadian and autonomic science. None of it is exotic. The value is in the sequence.
Gratitude first. He opens the day naming what he is grateful for, sometimes journaled, sometimes spoken with a partner. The spoken version, done with another person, adds a social-bonding layer. Naming positive affect early biases the day's emotional set point. How you feel at 4 p.m. is partly a symptom of how you aimed yourself in the morning.
A cold shower. Cold exposure drives a sharp sympathetic activation followed by a parasympathetic rebound, plus a sustained rise in norepinephrine and dopamine that supports alertness and mood for hours (Šrámek et al., 2000). This is reasonably well-supported physiology, though dose and individual response vary.
A 30-minute walk, ideally outdoors. Morning light is the single strongest input to your circadian clock through the retinohypothalamic pathway to the suprachiasmatic nucleus (Berson et al., 2002). Light early sets sleep pressure for that night. Movement adds the rest. I lay out the minimum effective version in Biohacking Your Morning, and the sleep payoff in Biohacking Sleep.
Ten minutes of meditation. Short, daily, consistent. The goal is to center the mind, connect mind to body, and contact feeling rather than staying stuck in the head.
Clean eating without the dogma. He calls himself an 80-to-90 percenter, eating whole foods while listening to what the body is asking for rather than what a rule dictates. That flexibility is the point. It keeps the practice from sliding into orthorexia.
Staying challenged. Muscle grows under load. The same logic applies to the brain. Voluntary discomfort, taking on something that scares you, drives the adaptation. A system that is never challenged does not strengthen. This connects directly to how you build durable change, which I cover in the neuroscience of making habits stick.
Why does laughing at yourself signal a regulated brain?
My guest made a claim that holds up neurologically: the ability to laugh at yourself is a marker of security, and the inability to do it often signals threat. Spiritual and wellness communities can build a preciousness around their beliefs that makes questioning feel dangerous. The person who cannot tolerate the joke is usually the one whose self-worth is fused to the belief.
He offered a sharp version of this. One of the most ego-driven things a person can do is try to be ego-free, because nothing flatters the ego more than appearing so evolved that it no longer exists. The neural read is that rigid identity defense, the need to protect a fixed self-image, runs on the same threat-and-control circuitry as any other defended position. Playfulness and non-attachment let the prefrontal regulators stay online. Seriousness and attachment pull you back into control.
This is the same axis as curiosity versus judgment, just pointed at the self instead of at a meditation cushion.
Putting it together
Comedy can be a useful tool. When a joke lands on a belief you hold tightly, your reaction tells you exactly how attached you are. The flinch is data.
The practical move is small and repeatable. When you catch yourself certain, controlling, or grading your own performance, swap the judgment for curiosity and watch what the threat circuitry does. Keep the morning routine simple: light, movement, a short meditation, and food you choose flexibly rather than dogmatically. Stay challenged enough to keep adapting. Hold your best practices firmly enough to do them and loosely enough to change them when the evidence shifts.
If you want to see what your own threat-and-control balance looks like in measurable terms, a QEEG brain map is where I start with people. It turns the abstract question of "am I too rigid" into something you can actually look at and train.
References
- Bratman (2000). Effective coupling of cyclotron autoresonance maser and "gyrotron" modes on a phase-synchronized electron beam. doi:10.1103/physreve.62.4207
- Menzies (2008). Grey matter abnormalities in trichotillomania: morphometric magnetic resonance imaging study. doi:10.1192/bjp.bp.107.048314
- Miller (2001). Profiling lipids across Caucasian and Afro-American hair transverse cuts, using synchrotron infrared microspectrometry. doi:10.1046/j.0412-5463.2001.00118.x
- Berson (2002). Mutated alleles of the rod and cone Na-Ca+K-exchanger genes in patients with retinal diseases. PMID 12037007